Cycling through winter can feel like a battle against the elements – icy winds that bite, rain that seeps, and roads that threaten to turn every corner into trip to A&E. For many, the solution starts and ends with overshoes, a quick fix to weatherproof their summer cycling shoes. But as temperatures plummet and the conditions grow harsher, overshoes can quickly reveal their limitations.
Enter winter cycling shoes – purpose-built for the season, combining warmth, waterproofing, and durability in a way overshoes simply can’t match. Whether you’re tackling frosty commutes or epic weekend rides, these boots are designed to keep your feet dry, warm, and comfortable, even when the forecast says otherwise. Here we'll answer some of your burning questions, and take a look at options from a few of the coolest cycling brands.
Winter cycling shoes or overshoes?
Overshoes are often the first line of defence against winter’s worst, but while they may seem like an easy fix, they fall short of true winter cycling shoes in both performance and resilience. Sure, they can block the wind, fend off water, and boost visibility, but overshoes rarely rival the warmth, waterproofing, and comfort of a dedicated winter boot.
Let’s not ignore the struggle of pulling them on with frosty fingers, either – an annoyance no one needs after a chilly ride. Winter cycling shoes, though, are built to brave the elements and, with proper care, will see you through many seasons. Overshoes, by comparison, are prone to ripping and wearing out, particularly when you’re walking off the bike. If you’re planning to ride through the depths of winter and can justify the spend, proper winter cycling shoes are an investment that pays dividends in comfort and durability.
The best winter cycling shoes to buy right now
Fizik Tempo Artica GTX
Winter road cycling kit has to defy the elements, and the Fizik Tempo Artica GTX rises to the challenge. Rather than simply shielding your feet, its GORE-TEX Insulated Koala membrane envelopes them in a cocoon of warmth and dryness, all while allowing breathability to flow unimpeded.
The outsole marries rigidity for power transfer with a design made for warmth, doing away with the vents that are commonplace in the bottom of most cycling shoes. A BOA Fit System cinches the shoe securely in seconds, while reflective accents amplify visibility during dusky rides.
Northwave Extreme R GTX
Engineered for die-hard road cyclists who don’t let a bit of bad weather get in the way of a good ride, the Northwave Extreme R GTX excels when the going gets tough. The lightweight carbon sole channels every watt of energy into forward motion with pinpoint efficiency, while the GORE-TEX membrane stands guard against rain and frost.
Northwave’s Arctic 4Layer insole cradles your foot with cosy insulation, making long winter rides feel bearable. The SLW2 dial twists into place, offering micro-adjustments that ensure a glove-like fit.
Fizik Terra Artica GTX
Crafted for gravel and off-road escapades, the Fizik Terra Artica GTX embraces the challenges of winter with gusto. Its GORE-TEX Insulated Koala membrane keeps moisture at bay and fortifies against biting cold while letting your feet breathe. The rugged Vibram sole clings to mud and ice with the tenacity of an off-road tyre, while the BOA Fit System locks things in tight. Reinforced toe and heel sections shield against the scrapes of rugged trails, and reflective accents keep you noticeable when daylight fades.
Northwave Celsius R Arctic GTX
Cycling through winter’s harshest offerings becomes manageable with the Northwave Celsius R Arctic GTX. This shoe braces against icy blasts with its GORE-TEX membrane, which locks out water while trapping warmth. The high-cut design swaddles your ankles, adding an extra layer of defence against the cold. Inside, the Arctic 4Layer insole cushions and insulates, ensuring feet stay comfortable no matter the conditions. The SLW2 closure system fine-tunes the fit, while an aggressive tread lets you stride confidently when dismounting is unavoidable.
DMT WKR1
Redefining winter cycling footwear, the DMT WKR1 combines aerodynamic design with functional prowess. Its clever knit upper conforms like a second skin, flexing with every movement for unparalleled comfort. The GORE-TEX Invisible Fit membrane weaves waterproofing into the fabric without compromising breathability, shielding you from rain while preventing overheating. Beneath, a carbon outsole channels energy seamlessly into your pedals, catering to riders who demand efficiency. Unique integrated lace loops tidy the silhouette, creating a sleek and aerodynamic profile. For cyclists who value form and function, the WKR1 is a masterclass in modern winter cycling tech.
Winter cycling shoe FAQs
Should I buy winter cycling shoes with road or MTB cleats?
Choosing between road and MTB-style cleats for winter cycling shoes boils down to how and where you ride. Road-specific shoes with three-bolt cleats are familiar territory for many, offering great power transfer and compatibility with road pedals. On the other hand, two-bolt MTB cleats bring rugged versatility, recessed into the outsole so you can tread confidently on icy café stops or muddy trails.
For smaller frames with mudguards, be mindful of potential toe overlap if you lean towards off-road cleats, as they can sit further back. Consider the terrain you’ll be tackling – and how often you might need to hop off your bike – when deciding which system fits your winter cycling needs.
Are winter cycling shoes waterproof?
Winter cycling shoes are designed to repel the elements with features like taped seams, water-resistant uppers, and GORE-TEX membranes. These innovations seal out moisture without trapping heat, keeping your feet dry and comfortable. Some models are crafted specifically for rain, while others focus on cold, dry weather – so pick your priorities.
That said, even the best waterproof shoes can be breached at the ankle. Water can creep down from soaked bib tights, turning your cosy setup into a soggy nightmare. A simple fix? Layer your tights over the boot cuff to block the flow. Unlike summer cycling shoes, winter models ditch sole vents to eliminate another entry point for water, ensuring better protection against winter’s wettest days.
Are winter cycling shoes warmer than overshoes?
Winter cycling shoes are engineered to stave off the chill, replacing the breezy vents of summer models with thermal linings and insulation. High ankle cuffs seal the gap between shoe and tights, locking in warmth and keeping cold air out. Some, like the Fizik Tempo Artica GTX, even include fleece linings or reflective foil insoles to retain heat during long rides.
However, not all tights play nice. Zipped ankle designs can press uncomfortably against boot cuffs, so check for compatibility. Thoughtful design, combined with advanced materials, makes winter cycling shoes a dependable choice for keeping frostbite at bay while you conquer cold-weather miles.
How do winter cycling shoes fit?
Winter cycling shoes are tailored to the season, accommodating thicker socks with roomier fits compared to their summer counterparts. While standard cycling shoes hug the foot for precision, winter models prioritise comfort and insulation, so you might notice a touch more space.
Their soles often flex more than those of high-performance road shoes, providing better walking comfort for off-bike moments. As always, trying them on is key – especially if you’re planning to pair them with plush winter socks. The right fit ensures not just warmth but also better pedal efficiency for winter training sessions.
Next up: Take a look at the coolest cycling clothing brands on the scene.
